David Kinnear: The Debate Over Charter Schools

Home/David Kinnear: The Debate Over Charter Schools

This month, new leaders and policymakers will begin taking office in Washington. Many of them have pledged to tackle what is perhaps the most contentious issue in education right now: school choice.

classroom-1910011_960_720

The question of whether charter schools boost academic achievement forms the core of education policy debates nationwide and at the state level. Unfortunately, media coverage of this issue tends to be unproductively narrow. Charter schools are often misrepresented and misunderstood, eclipsed by the polarized political arguments in which they are enmeshed. I find that parents’ voices are underrepresented in the debate over charter schools, which distorts the focus of the conversation. As a result, critics overlook the fact that families often seek out charter schools in order to get their children’s basic needs met.

students-1177711_960_720

Charter schools are a relatively new phenomenon – their underlying concept was developed by teachers during the 1980s and early ‘90s in tandem with other ideas for education innovation and reform. As originally conceived, an ideal charter school would function as a legally and financially autonomous public school (without tuition, no religious affiliation or selective student admissions) and as such, would be free to customize and manage the school to meet the specific needs of its students.

board-1666644_960_720

Two decades later, charter schools have evolved as a way to experiment with education innovations and provide public school choice–especially in communities where access to high-quality education is limited or nonexistent.

The major difference between charter schools and traditional public schools is the autonomy charter schools enjoy in terms of staffing, curriculum requirements, and budget management.  This is also what makes these institutions notoriously difficult to evaluate on a larger scale.

pre-1272291_960_720

That charters lack the bureaucratic red tape which so often plagues schools subject to traditional governance can be advantageous. Charters are able to initiate reform without the burdensome policies, administrative obstacles and entrenched legacy issues that hinder some of the traditional school systems in this country.

classroom-1699745_960_720

Today’s students are the next generation of American doers and thinkers, and as a country we rely on them to keep the United States on the forefront of innovation and progress. To ensure those students can succeed, our country’s publicly-funded education system must be strengthened. And successful charter schools represent one way, but certainly not the only way, to improve our country’s education landscape.

kids-1093758_960_720

2017-06-19T10:25:46+00:00 January 5th, 2017|0 Comments

About the Author:

David Kinnear is a Financial Professional with Wells Fargo Advisors. He was ranked among Barron’s Top Financial Advisors in 2009, 2011, 2012, and 2014. Chicago Magazine recognizes David as a Five Star Wealth Manager and frequently appears on the Magazine’s list of Top 50 Financial Advisors in Chicago. David Kinnear lives with his family in Chicago’s Lincoln Park neighborhood. He and his wife, Andrea, have two sons and a wirehaired pointing griffon.

Leave A Comment